Should I Get a New Puppy or Get a Rescue Dog?

by | May 15, 2023

You have now decided that it is time to get a dog to share your life, and that of your household, and your question is should I get a new puppy or get a rescue dog?

Over the years I have asked myself this question many times, my heart swings between providing a home to a dog that may have been surrendered due to family issues for one reason or another, sometimes sad and unforeseen issues, or even being carelessly looked after, and therefore a new home is in this dog’s best interests, or wait for it, a new puppy?

Would You Like to Know How to Train Your Dog?
Three FREE Training Videos Available NOW! 

It is a decision that tugs at your heartstrings, doesn’t it?  However, either decision needs to be well thought through.

Sometimes we have to think with our head and not our heart.  The reasons for this could be endless, do we have enough finances to keep this animal in top condition when it may have ongoing issues with its personality.  These issues could keep us out of pocket.

I have noticed a trend in the last few years whereby animal shelters may describe the dog as needing one owner, and not a family with children and needing care when out socialising.  This rings alarm bells in me straight away.

When choosing a dog from an animal shelter or pet rescue society I believe it is in your best interest to learn about a dog’s body language prior to visiting dogs being offered for adoption.  A dog’s demeanour can tell you a lot.  Plus, you need to ask lots of questions about the dog that you may be considering. 

How does this particular dog react to you?  What are its ears and body telling you?  Take the dog for a walk around its present home and ask to see the dog interact with another dog within its present environment.  Does this dog react to loud noises or by you waving your arms about?  You also need to consider that this dog may have issues that are not apparent at your initial meeting.  Or maybe this dog is simply shy at this meeting.  Understanding body language, even in part, can be so helpful in  helping you make an informed decision and not be caught up with your heart decision.  Of course, you need to want to be with this dog and to warm to its physical appearance in your own mind.

This is now a good time to ask yourself, should I get a new puppy or get a rescue dog?

If you have decided to broaden your horizons, so to speak, this may be a good time to look into the pros and cons of maybe getting a new puppy.

If a new puppy, ask yourself if you prefer an active breed or a quieter breed, a long haired dog that needs to be groomed or a short-haired breed, a small medium or large breed, or a dog that doesn’t shed a lot of hair?  These questions give you an idea of what you need to consider, and not to forget your family dynamics, a single household, a busy household, family with children, family with adults? 

There is a lot to consider.

I have had cross-breeds and pedigree dogs over the years, have bred dogs, have rescued dogs, and have bought puppies.  So, what is my preference you may ask?

Hard question!  Both decisions have their merits and issues. 

I must admit, I do have a soft spot for raising my own puppy, and yes, this means working through puppy biting, puppy destruction, digging, toilet training, socialising, barking, walking on a leash without taking me for a “sled ride”, and I could carry on with this list! 

In my case, it is so rewarding working through these growing stages, as my end goal for this puppy is for him or her to be calm, have boundaries, understand the household routine, and for this puppy to know that I am a consistent and fair leader.  This growing puppy will know it is loved.   When you have a dog that is a very welcome and loved member of your family situation, it’s so worth it.

I certainly would not leave out the positives you can gain from rehoming a dog that needs a forever home from your loving care and guidance.  Sometimes you may not have the time or inclination to raise a new puppy, so by all means, pursue that special rehomed dog that you can build a bond with, but, please go armed with all the knowledge and information that will help you make an informed decision.

I pray that whichever decision you make … should I get a new puppy or get a rescue dog, I am trusting your decision will provide you with a great loyal companion to share your life with.

Would You Like to Know How to Train Your Dog?
Three FREE Training Videos Available NOW! 

Until next time…

With Love, Success and Inspiration

Robin Oliver

www.robinoliveronline.com/blog

Spread the love
Transform your pup’s behavior with positive reinforcement! Enroll now and see the difference!

With Love, Success and Inspiration,

Robin Oliver

Robin Oliver Pet Dog Training
Professional Dog Trainer

APDT Logo_RobinOliver